59 Comments

Hi, what do you recommend for ice cream storage containers (capacity, shape, material?) I used a plastic deli container for this delicious ice cream (a hit with my 2 and 4 year old boys!) and that cracked when scooping. Thanks!

Expand full comment

I have read all the comments and no one had a problem making the ice cream so it must be me. I put the ice cream in the fridge to cool and the next morning it was like a very thick pudding and I couldn’t pour it into the ice cream maker, I had to scoop it in. By the time I got it all in, the first stuff was done and the last stuff wasn’t. The ice cream turned out very dry and hard to scoop. It seemed like it needed another cup of milk to give it the right consistency. I don’t know what I did wrong but it didn’t turn out well. What consistency is it supposed to be when it is cooled? Should I have been able to pour it?

Expand full comment

Depending on the chocolate you used, it can be quite thick before churning. You can whisk it to make it more pourable if desired. The ice cream does use milk rather than cream so the texture will be a bit firmer, but mine was scoopable and you can see the texture of it as it came out of the machine at the top of the post.

Expand full comment

My mind is not entirely in gear so why is there two times the recipe in this post? (both "versions" seem the same - Having the same amount of cream/sugar)

Expand full comment

I think because I am working on a print version of recipes it showed up twice for some readers but it's been corrected.

Expand full comment

I have the new edition of The Perfect Scoop and I love it! But oh, there was parsley ice cream in the older edition???!! Wow, does that sound like I would love it! I looked online to see if I could find the recipe, and I found someone's adaptation of it. Would love to see yours. Do I have to track down an earlier edition?

Expand full comment

Yes it’s in the first edition of the book.

Expand full comment

Just curious as to the type of ice cream freezer that you use. I had a Cuisinart for years and it finally quit. I bought a Whynter so I don’t have to freeze the container. However I haven’t been terribly happy with the results. Any suggestions?

Expand full comment

Hi Tami: I mentioned it in a previous comment (but I know there are a lot of comments to scroll through...):

"It's a Cuisinart (ICE-50) which is no longer being made. I want to upgrade to the newer model (but it has a digital touchpad and I'm always wary of those since they seem to be the first to go on electronic appliances...) but a flash shopping site in France has them on sale right now...so I may just go for it! (I hear the Breville machine is very good but haven't had a chance to try or use one.)"

I will likely upgrade to the newer Cuisinart or Breville next time.

Expand full comment

Thank you. Keep writing great books! I think have them all.

Expand full comment

In Oregon there is a company called Chocosphere that sells dozens of different brands and many varieties of those brands. They have a dizzying and dazzling list of chocolates available, including giandujas. You order online and in my experience, shipment is very quick. Chocosphere.com is the website. I have been ordering from them for years and I’ve never been disappointed. You do have to order in bulk, which is something to consider, but if you use a lot of chocolate, as I do, this is not a problem.

Expand full comment

They're a good company and have been around a while - I do buy chocolate in bulk as it's more economical and easier to have it around for baking.

Expand full comment

Yes, yes, this chocolate ice cream recipe is wonderful. BUT your Gianduja Gelato recipe (with stracciatella of course) is divine!

Expand full comment

Well funny this came up today - I just made your chocolate coconut sorbet and set it on the porch to chill. It is from the Ready for Dessert book. This is one of my all time favorite recipes for ice cream not made with cream - hence the sorbet label. It's perfect and always a hit for a dinner party with those stellar pain d' amande. A combination made for each other. Thank you, thank you for your love of chocolate and inspired recipes.

Expand full comment

I needed that translation for French press this past fall. While being shown around our air b and b I tried to ask what was available for making coffee and French press or bialetti both were not understood. I assumed it was my bad pronunciation

Expand full comment

Generally in France the Bialetti is called a 'moka' but I've heard it referred to as a Bialetti. It was funny when I brought up the "French press" ... and none of my French friends at the dinner I was at knew what I was talking about (until I explained it but they didn't know it was French)

: )

Expand full comment

Looks delicious!

Expand full comment

When I was last in Japan, I tried soy sauce ice cream, and to my amazement, it was fantastic. I’ve taken to adding a tablespoon of double brewed soy sauce to my ice cream recipes (leaving out the salt) and it adds a caramel umami taste and also keeps it scoopable. I’ve yet to have anyone guess my secret ingredient. Double brewed soy sauce is a lot less salty, don’t use regular soy sauce.

Expand full comment

People have taken to adding miso to desserts, including ice cream so soy sauce isn't that far off. There is a Kinako (roasted Japanese soy powder) ice cream in the first edition of The Perfect Scoop, that would be perfect with that touch of soy sauce. (That was one of the recipes I took out of the revised edition to make room for other recipes so it's only in the first book.)

Expand full comment

That is so interesting. I've never seen double brewed soy sauce. Could you recommend a brand?

Expand full comment

I used Kikkoman because it was readily available. I did pick up another fancier brand but haven’t opened it yet. I had the ice cream at the Yamato soy sauce store in Kanazawa, so if you can find their brand it would most likely be good.

Expand full comment

A friend recently gifted me a 200 gm bar of 100% cacao chocolate that he purchased at a cacao farm In Peru. He bought it in error for himself thinking it was just a dark chocolate bar…not tasty at all! Guess I will give it a whirl in the original recipe from Last Scoop. Like your recipe for chocolate sorbet it includes dark cocoa powder (I use Valrhona) Another gem of a recipe, thanks David.

Expand full comment

Their cocoa powder is really excellent. I don't like to call for brands in my recipes unless it really makes a difference (and their cocoa powder is more expensive than other brands) but I do like to use it a lot.

Expand full comment

Thank you for posting this recipe. It’s timely as here in the US stores are running out of eggs and when they have them they are expensive.

I’d forgotten that The Perfect Scoop has an eggless chocolate ice cream recipe. I appreciate the reminder.

Expand full comment

Second only to my pomegranate ice cream with a splash of PAMA pomegranate liqueur, this chocolate ice cream is absolutely superb!! I have served with a scoop of both the p. and the choc - sweet and tart combo works well - and guests swoon. I thank you so much for your wonderful newsletters!! LaVonne B

Expand full comment

Hi David, I want to thank you for the Perfect Scoop! There really is something for everyone in this cookbook. The chocolate ice cream with peanut butter patty mix ins have become a family favorite.

I too have the Breville/Sage mixer and was so excited to pair it with your recipes I made 3 ice creams in one day! Thanks again!

Expand full comment

Am glad you like the book so much - and are making good use of your ice cream machine!

Expand full comment