49 Comments

The key instruction that elevates this salted butter caramel sauce is: "keep gently stirring, as it gets smokier". At that point take the pot off the stove and add the cream I love that slightly bitter, sweet, caramel taste with a bit of flaky salt. made it three times and shared the recipe. The Best!

Expand full comment

Oh, gosh, David. I made this today and followed your instructions precisely. It went well, but the sauce appears to be thin and has a bitter back taste.

Might I have over warmed the cream, it was more hot than warm, and can I add something to make the sauce less bitter? I assume that when the sauce is refrigerated and cools, it will thicken?

Thanks for your help,

Carol.

Expand full comment

I haven’t tried this method- the butter and sugar together. I wonder about the milk solids from the butter and burning? I will try it- your recipes have never let me down! I guess my question is why not a dry caramel, add the butter and then cream? Or cream and then butter? Obviously would affect the water portion from the butter not cooking off. I almost feel like doing a side by side comparison LOL

Expand full comment

Do you think if I use a canning method this sauce will last on the shelf?

Expand full comment

Hi, I made the sauce this afternoon and it tastes so rich! But it is thin! I got it to the dirty penny stage and it was smoking. I must have erred on the side of scared of burning and pulled it off then added the cream as directed. To get it thicker, should I have been braver and let it almost burn? Thanks for any help and loving your newsletters!

Expand full comment

Yum!

Expand full comment

I have and love those spatulas from LC. My new favs are from Thermoworks. I threw a couple in my order for a new thermometer (which I also love) and was pleasantly surprised how often I reach for them over the LC. Many colors to chose from and they’re made completely of high temp silicone.

Expand full comment

I can't speak to shipping costs from the US, but spoon-shaped silicone spatulas are available from therestaurantstore.com (several choices) and bakedeco.com (just 1 from Rubbermaid).

Expand full comment

You can still get those in my local Le Creuset outlet store! Also: you failed to mention why I love the Le Creuset spatulas so much - they're heatproof, which I've learned to my detriment making caramel that not all spatulas are...

Expand full comment

Can you just leave out the flaky salt? I am SO over salty desserts and can't wait until bakeries stop making delicious chocolate chip cookies and then dumping clumps of salt across the top :(

Expand full comment

Love my solid silicone spoons; they do better in the dishwasher

Expand full comment

I love to add a splash of bourbon to this sauce; gives it a smoky edge that’s sublime with roasted peaches, vanilla ice cream etc. cheers Karen

Expand full comment

The US Le Creuset website has some that look like the ones in your photo. https://www.lecreuset.com/craft-series-spatula-spoon/JS420.html

Expand full comment

Thanks for showing the photos of the crystallized sugar and separated butter. It gives me confidence to be able to make this recipe.

Expand full comment

Timely recipe! When our 3 kids, their spouses and 6 grands gather at our Northern Michigan lake house in the summer, make your own sundaes are always on the menu! This salted caramel sauce will no doubt be a huge hit! The oven will also be on. As they say, if you can’t stand the heat, get out of the kitchen! I love reading your newsletters. I’m sorry it’s going to be so very hot in France this week. One of your iced cold cocktails may be needed! Cheers!!!!

Expand full comment

I love caramel sauce on ice cream. In the recipe you call for 3/4 cup of sugar. What would be your weight conversion for that? I’m not a cup person I’m afraid :-)

Thanks,

Expand full comment