65 Comments

I have a Meyer lemon tree in my front yard in Santa Cruz, and I’m definitely going to try this recipe soon. I’ve made the lemon custard from the Green’s cookbook a bunch of times, but your recipe looks great.

Expand full comment

Wonderful, easy pudding.

Expand full comment

Lovely to see this wonderful dessert here. It is called Lemon Delicious in Australia and is an old favourite from my childhood. BTW I have a wonderful Lisbon lemon tree in my very small garden. Strongly prefer Lisbons. Real lemons. 😊

Expand full comment

So delicious, thank you for sharing! First dessert of the new year and we were over the moon to start it with very lemony deliciousness.

Expand full comment

I made it in a deep dish pie pan

Expand full comment

Hi David, this was crazy delicious and we had to restrain ourselves from eating the whole thing the first night, finished it last night. Mine came out much darker than yours did, almost burnt looking, at 35 minutes. I had it on the middle rack. Do I need to move to a lower rack or just check it earlier?

Expand full comment

Glad you liked it! Everyone's oven is different and when I'm baking I usually keep an eye on things - no matter what, and if something seems to be getting too dark on top, I move it down or drape it with foil.

Expand full comment

Made it last night and it was really good. Thanks David.

Expand full comment

"Cerave" unscented moisturizer in large bottles at great prices at the Pharmacy at 26 Rue du Four (corner of rue de Four and rue Bonaparte) in the 6th just off of blvd Saint-Germain. Unfortunately, you'll have to leave the 11th but it is worth it. I shop there regularly.

Expand full comment

they now sell Cerave at most pharmacies in Paris but always surprised how much perfume and fragrances are added to products, including laundry detergents. It’s impossible to find unscented shaving cream too :-/

Expand full comment

She's getting up there in years, so she probably doesn't get out much these days.

Expand full comment

Just curious--do you know my author friend Diane (Murray) Johnson? I have an impression that Americans in Paris get to know one another. She's a novelist and a great cook!

Constance Malloy

Expand full comment

I met her many years ago but I haven’t seen her since

Expand full comment

Hi, David. I'm at my aunt's in Sacramento. She has three lemon trees! We just moved her to assisted living, so I'm going to make her your pudding and take it tomorrow. Thanks! Constance

Expand full comment

Made this tonight to eat after dinner of wine braised chicken and mushrooms (we’re in Montpellier). Easy and so delicious!!!

Expand full comment

glad you liked it!

Expand full comment

it's a keeper for sure! By the way, we absolutely loved your book on renovating your apartment in Paris. It was a good guide for us when we were looking for our place in Montpellier.

Expand full comment

The way I now have an insatiable craving for this lemon pudding!! Saving for when I visit family in Arizona next month. I live in New York City and picking fresh lemons for this from their backyard tree will be a sure highlight of my trip.

Expand full comment

Having fresh lemons is a wonderful thing. It's one of the things I miss about living on the West Coast...all those lemons and citrus : )

Expand full comment

Very much agree! The best.

Expand full comment

looks amazing! could i substitute the butter w/ margarine and the milk w/ almond milk to make it non-dairy? pls let me know asap as i'd like to make it for my guests on friday night. love your newsletter! 175k subscribers is a big deal! dan

Expand full comment

I've only made the recipe as written. I think plant-based margarines work like butter but haven't tried it with it, or plant-based milk. But if you do try them, let us know how they turn out as others are asking the same questions : )

Expand full comment

I may have to consider this when my meyer lemons ripen, hopefully in the next month. thank you

Expand full comment

When the memory of the butterscotch pudding I made last week (using Muscovado dark brown sugar) recedes, I will make this. I even have blackberries in the freezer. And raspberries . . . raspberry sauce or coulis could be gorgeous with it.

With a small household, I appreciate that the recipe makes four servings, since pudding does not age well.

David: To replace the white flour with tapioca granules or tapioca flour, would the amount be half of the amount of all-purpose flour in the recipe, as for cornstarch, as you say in your newsletter? Merci!

Expand full comment

I don't know about tapioca flour/granules vs. wheat flour but Bob's Red Mill mentioned how to substitute it, and what ratios, here: https://www.bobsredmill.com/blog/healthy-living/what-is-tapioca-flour-where-does-it-come-from/

Expand full comment

Thanks for the link. It says: "Despite its name, tapioca flour is a starch that makes a great gluten free thickener. Instead of using wheat flour to thicken a soup or dressing, you can use tapioca flour to achieve the same effect. Commonly substituted at a 1:1 1/2 ratio, we recommend first creating a slurry of tapioca flour and then adding it to your recipe. Doing so will ensure that the tapioca flour is evenly distributed and help prevent clumping. "

I'm assuming that in their ratio, the "1" is APF and the "1 1/2" is tapioca flour/starch. Hope correct!

Expand full comment